(845) 986-2777
24 Main Street, Warwick, NY 10990
(212) 203-7710
450 7th Avenue, 33rd Fl, New York, NY 10123

New York Court of Appeals Rules on Social Media Discovery in Personal Injury Lawsuit

New York Court of Appeals Rules on Social Media Discovery in Personal Injury Lawsuit

For more information, please contact The Ahearne Law Firm, PLLC at (845) 986-2777 for an initial consultation and case evaluation.

In the recent unanimous decision of Forman v. Henkin, 2018 N.Y. Slip Op 01015 — a personal injury lawsuit wherein the plaintiff claimed spine and traumatic brain injuries after she fell from a horse owned by defendant, leading to cognitive deficits, memory loss, problems writing, and social isolation — the New York Court of Appeals ruled that private materials of a Facebook user are subject to discovery if they contain material relevant to the issues in controversy in litigation.

Kelly Forman said she became a recluse after suffering a spinal injury and brain damage, making it hard to read and write, in a June 2011 fall caused by Mark Henkin’s negligence in fitting her horse with a defective stirrup that broke. Forman testified during her deposition that she had a Facebook account to which she had posted pre-accident photographs, but that she had closed the account after the accident. Henkin moved to gain access to, among other things, the entirety of Forman’s private Facebook account, claiming that any photographs and messages she had posted to Facebook would contain information relevant to deposition testimony that she could no longer cook, travel, engage in sports, ride a horse, or go to the movies, and now had difficulty reading, writing, reasoning, and using a computer.

The Supreme Court granted Henkin’s motion, but limiting the disclosure to all photographs Forman had posted privately on Facebook before the accident which she intended to use at trial and all photographs of herself she had posted privately on Facebook after the accident, but excluding any photos which may have depicted nudity or romantic relationships. Upon Forman’s appeal, the Appellate Division, First Department limited the disclosure to photographs (pre-accident or post-accident) that Forman intended to use at trial.

The Court of Appeals reversed the Appellate Division and reinstated the order of Supreme Court, stating that, “while Facebook—and sites like it—offer relatively new means of sharing information with others, there is nothing so novel about Facebook materials that precludes application of New York’s long-standing disclosure rules to resolve this dispute,” while “reject[ing] the notion that the account holders so‑called “privacy” settings govern the scope of disclosure of social media materials,” as “even private materials may be subject to discovery if they are relevant.” The court also cautioned that a personal injury lawsuit does not make a person’s entire social media data “automatically discoverable.”

#NewYork #personalinjury #lawsuit #accident #socialmedia #Facebook

If you or a family member have suffered an accident or injury, you and/or your family member may be entitled to money damages.

We take your calls and meet with your family personally to answer all your questions. We will press your insurance company for the coverage you are entitled to and help you recover the compensation you deserve. Personal injury cases require a wealth of experience, and a network of proven experts, including doctors and medical experts, accident recreation experts, insurance investigators, private investigators, and the resources necessary to fight large insurance companies.

All of our personal injury cases are contingency cases, which means you pay nothing out of pocket and we do not get paid unless you get paid.

The Ahearne Law Firm, PLLC
Offices in Manhattan and Warwick, New York
Serving New York City, Long Island, Orange County, and the Hudson Valley
Mass tort lawsuits handled nationwide, including the national prescription opiate litigation, Stryker Rejuvenate / ABG II hip implants and LFIT V40 femoral head, DePuy Pinnacle and ASR hip implants, Smith & Nephew BHR hip implant, and ZimmerBiomet Durom Hip Cup and M2A Magnum hip implant
Personal Injury · Product Liability · Medical Malpractice  Commercial Litigation · Criminal Defense · Corporate Counsel Real Estate
For more information, please contact The Ahearne Law Firm, PLLC at (845) 986-2777 for an initial consultation and case evaluation.