Construction sites present a unique set of hazards that can lead to life-changing injuries for workers and visitors in Buffalo. If you or a loved one were hurt on a job site, understanding your rights and the legal pathways available under New York law is essential to protecting recovery options. The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC serves injured people across Erie County, offering practical guidance and clear next steps. Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. and the firm’s team focus on construction incidents such as falls, collapses, and equipment accidents, and can explain how claims under New York Labor Law, third-party negligence, and workers’ compensation may interact in your situation.
A construction injury claim in New York can involve multiple legal paths, including workers’ compensation, Labor Law claims, and third-party negligence actions, and each path carries different rules, deadlines, and potential outcomes. Getting timely guidance helps ensure evidence is preserved, deadlines are met, and communications with insurers or employers do not unintentionally harm a claim. Effective representation helps navigate complex medical records, coordinate benefits, and pursue fair compensation for medical bills, lost income, pain and suffering, and long-term care needs. When injuries are serious or liability is contested, having a structured plan for the claim process improves the chance of a comprehensive resolution.
New York Labor Law 240, commonly referenced in construction injury cases, imposes a duty on owners and contractors to provide proper safety devices and safeguards for work performed at heights or involving the use of dangerous equipment. Under this provision, injured workers may recover for gravity-related risks such as falls when safety measures like guardrails, harnesses, or secure scaffolding were not provided. This law is distinct from workers’ compensation and can allow for recovery from parties other than the employer when inadequate safety protections directly contribute to an injury at a work site.
A third-party claim arises when someone other than the injured worker’s employer bears responsibility for an accident. Examples include a subcontractor whose equipment malfunctioned, a property owner who failed to maintain safe conditions, or a manufacturer of defective gear. Pursuing a third-party claim can provide access to additional compensation beyond workers’ compensation benefits, for items such as pain and suffering and future lost earnings. Establishing liability in such claims typically requires evidence showing negligent actions or defective equipment that contributed directly to the injury.
Workers’ compensation provides no-fault benefits to employees who suffer workplace injuries, covering medical treatment and a portion of lost wages regardless of who was at fault. While it offers essential immediate support, workers’ compensation does not typically compensate for non-economic losses such as pain and suffering. In construction cases, a worker may still pursue separate claims against third parties or certain employers under New York Labor Law for additional recovery. The interplay between workers’ compensation and civil claims requires careful coordination to ensure benefits and any additional recoveries are handled correctly.
OSHA is the federal agency responsible for setting and enforcing workplace safety standards and conducting investigations when unsafe conditions are reported. In construction incidents, OSHA may inspect the site, issue citations, or require corrective measures when safety violations are identified. OSHA findings can be useful when documenting unsafe conditions that contributed to an injury, but OSHA enforcement is separate from civil claims and does not replace the remedies available through New York law. Documentation of inspections, citations, or corrective orders can support a claim by highlighting lapses in required safety practices.
After a construction accident, take photos and videos of the scene, equipment involved, and any visible injuries as soon as it is safe to do so, because visual evidence can be crucial when reconstructing events later. Note the names and contact information of any coworkers and on-site witnesses, and save copies of safety logs or incident reports provided by the employer. Keep a contemporaneous record of your symptoms and medical visits so that the sequence of events and your treatment needs are clearly documented for claim purposes.
Getting immediate medical attention serves both your health needs and the documentation of the injury, so visit an emergency room or treat with a healthcare provider right away if you were hurt on site. Follow-up appointments, diagnostic testing, and treatment plans should be recorded and preserved, as these records form the backbone of a claim for medical expenses and future care. Inform providers about how the injury occurred and keep copies of all medical bills, referral notes, and prescribed therapies to support any recovery efforts.
Do not discard equipment, clothing, or safety gear involved in the incident; preserving these items can help demonstrate the condition of tools and protective devices at the time of the accident. Keep original documents such as incident reports, payroll records, and correspondence with insurers or employers, and provide copies to counsel when reviewing the case. Avoid making public statements about the accident on social media, and direct questions from insurers or others to your representative so that communications are managed with the claim’s objectives in mind.
When injuries result in long-term disability, significant medical expenses, or ongoing care needs, pursuing a comprehensive claim that addresses all potential sources of recovery is often appropriate because short-term benefits may not cover future losses. Comprehensive claims coordinate workers’ compensation benefits with third-party claims and Labor Law actions to seek full compensation for medical costs, loss of earning capacity, and non-economic damages. A thorough approach helps identify all responsible parties and build a record that supports recovery for both immediate and future needs related to a serious work injury.
Construction sites often involve owners, general contractors, subcontractors, equipment manufacturers, and suppliers, and when more than one party may share responsibility, a comprehensive claim is needed to pursue recovery from each potentially liable source. Identifying multiple defendants can increase the likelihood of obtaining full compensation for losses that workers’ compensation alone will not address. Coordinating claims against different parties also helps ensure that settlement negotiations and any offsets are managed to protect the injured person’s overall recovery and future care requirements.
If an injury is minor, treatment is brief, and the medical prognosis indicates a full recovery, a limited approach focusing on workers’ compensation benefits and direct negotiation with insurers may be sufficient for resolving immediate costs. In such situations, pursuing an extensive civil claim may not be necessary and could involve time and expense that outweighs the potential recovery. However, even seemingly minor injuries should be documented and monitored to ensure that delayed complications are not overlooked, and to preserve the ability to pursue additional remedies if conditions change.
When an injury is clearly covered by workers’ compensation and the benefits adequately address medical costs and wage replacement, proceeding through the workers’ compensation system alone can be a practical option that provides prompt support. This approach is often suitable when no third party contributed to the incident and there is no basis for a separate civil claim under Labor Law. Still, it is important to confirm that workers’ compensation covers all anticipated needs and to preserve documentation that would support any future claims if new issues arise.
Falls from scaffolds and ladders remain a leading cause of severe injury on construction sites, often resulting from improper installation, missing guardrails, unsecured platforms, or lack of fall protection at elevated work areas, and these incidents frequently produce fractures, head trauma, and long-term disability that require extensive medical care. Proper documentation of the scaffold condition, witness accounts, and employer safety practices can be critical to showing that required safeguards were absent or inadequate and to establishing liability under applicable New York rules for work performed at heights.
Trench and excavation collapses can cause crushing injuries, entrapment, and catastrophic consequences when protective shoring, sloping, or shielding are not in place or when soil conditions are misjudged, and timely rescue and medical intervention are essential to survival and recovery. Evidence of site preparation, soil testing, and compliance with safety protocols, along with testimony about training and supervision, helps clarify whether a collapse resulted from preventable hazards or insufficient protective measures.
Electrical incidents, including shocks and arc flash events, can cause severe burns, neurological injury, and long-term health impacts when circuits are not de-energized, protective equipment is missing, or wiring is faulty, and these events often require specialized medical care and rehabilitation. Documentation such as incident reports, maintenance logs, and records of training or lockout/tagout procedures can be essential in determining whether negligent practices or defective equipment contributed to the injury.
Ahearne Law Firm PLLC offers focused representation for individuals injured on construction sites in Buffalo and Erie County, providing clear guidance about immediate steps to protect a claim and coordinating medical documentation and evidence collection. The firm’s approach emphasizes direct communication, attention to the specific facts of each accident, and practical strategies for pursuing all available recovery avenues under New York law. When employers, contractors, or equipment providers may share liability, the firm assists in identifying relevant parties and assembling a case that addresses both current and anticipated needs.
Seek medical attention as soon as possible, even if injuries seem minor, because some conditions can worsen over time and prompt documentation of treatment is important for any later claim. Notify the site supervisor or employer about the incident so that there is an official record, and gather basic evidence such as photos of the scene, the equipment involved, and contact information for witnesses. Keep copies of incident reports and medical records and avoid posting details about the accident on social media, as public statements can affect later claims. Preserving physical evidence such as clothing or tools involved in the accident can be helpful when reconstructing what happened. Make careful notes about how the incident occurred and the names of those present, and retain correspondence with insurers and employers. If you plan to seek review of your situation, an early consultation will help clarify deadlines, the likely avenues for recovery under New York law, and practical steps to protect your claim while you focus on recovery.
An employer may be responsible through workers’ compensation for medical treatment and wage replacement regardless of fault, but in New York construction incidents certain claims, including those under Labor Law provisions, can be brought against owners or contractors responsible for unsafe conditions. Direct claims against an employer outside workers’ compensation are limited in some circumstances, but careful review of the facts will determine whether additional civil claims are available against other parties involved at the site. The relationship between workers’ compensation and civil claims should be evaluated early to preserve all recovery options. If a third party such as a subcontractor, equipment manufacturer, or property owner contributed to the accident, pursuing a claim against those parties can provide compensation for losses not covered by workers’ compensation, including pain and suffering and future lost earnings. Documentation of site safety practices, maintenance records, and witness statements will be important for establishing liability, so retain evidence and report the incident promptly so potential claims can be assessed and pursued without unnecessary delay.
Workers’ compensation provides no-fault benefits that cover medical treatment and wage replacement for many injured workers, and acceptance of those benefits does not always preclude pursuing additional claims against non-employer parties whose negligence contributed to the accident. When a third party or an owner or contractor failed to provide required safety measures, separate civil claims under New York law may be available to seek broader compensation. Coordinating these claims requires careful handling so that recovery sources are identified and offsets or liens are addressed properly. Understanding how to combine workers’ compensation benefits with other civil actions is important because workers’ compensation benefits may be reimbursable from third-party recoveries under certain rules. A coordinated approach helps ensure that medical bills and benefits are covered while pursuing compensation for non-economic losses and long-term impacts, and it reduces the risk of unintended reductions in overall recovery due to mismanagement of overlapping claims.
New York Labor Law 240 is often called the Scaffold Law and imposes strict responsibilities on owners and contractors to provide adequate safety devices or safeguards for workers performing elevation-related tasks or using certain equipment. The statute focuses on protecting workers from gravity-related risks by requiring proper guardrails, scaffolding, hoists, and fall protection, and it allows injured workers to bring claims against those who fail to provide such protections when a fall or similar incident occurs. The law differs from workers’ compensation by permitting certain civil claims for damages beyond wage replacement and medical benefits. Because the law imposes broad duties on owners and contractors, proving a claim under this provision typically involves showing that required safety devices were not provided or were inadequate for the work being performed. Evidence such as site photographs, equipment maintenance records, witness statements, and safety logs can help establish that the lack of appropriate safeguards contributed directly to the injury, supporting a claim for additional compensation beyond what workers’ compensation provides.
Deadlines for filing claims depend on the type of action and the laws that apply. For civil actions in New York, statutes of limitations vary by claim type and may be relatively short, so it is important to act quickly to preserve the right to sue. Workers’ compensation claims also have specific timelines for reporting injuries to employers and filing for benefits, and failure to meet those deadlines can jeopardize recovery. Prompt reporting to your employer and timely medical evaluation are key steps for preserving both benefit claims and potential civil actions. Because the applicable time limits can differ depending on whether a claim is pursued under workers’ compensation, Labor Law, or third-party negligence, an early review of your situation will identify the relevant deadlines and necessary filings. If you believe you have a construction injury claim, gather records and seek guidance soon so that filing requirements are met and evidence is preserved for an effective presentation of your case.
Many construction injury claims resolve through negotiation and settlement without a full trial, as parties often prefer to avoid the time and uncertainty of court proceedings. However, if the case cannot be resolved fairly through settlement, it may proceed to litigation and ultimately to trial where a judge or jury decides the issues. The prospect of litigation depends on the specific facts, the strength of the evidence, and the willingness of insurers or defendants to offer a reasonable settlement that addresses medical needs and other losses. Preparing a case for potential court action involves gathering medical records, expert opinions as needed, witness statements, and site documentation, and this preparation strengthens the position during settlement talks as well. Whether a case goes to court, the objective remains the same: to secure fair compensation for medical care, lost income, and other damages, and to pursue a resolution that addresses both present and future needs related to the injury.
Recoverable damages in construction injury claims can include past and future medical expenses, lost wages and loss of earning capacity, rehabilitation and assistive care costs, and compensation for pain and suffering and diminished quality of life. The specific types and amounts of damages depend on the severity of the injury, the anticipated future medical needs, and the economic impact on the injured person’s ability to work and live independently. Accurate documentation of medical treatment, wage records, and expert assessments of future needs supports a demand for appropriate compensation. In some cases additional losses such as household services, transportation for medical care, and conversion or loss of retirement or other benefits may also be considered when calculating damages. The goal is to address both immediate financial burdens and the long-term effects of the injury so that compensation reflects the full scope of the harm suffered and the care that may be needed going forward.
Fault in a construction accident is determined by examining the actions or omissions of parties present at the site, the adequacy of safety measures, compliance with industry standards, and documentation such as maintenance logs and incident reports. Witness statements, photographs, and records of training and supervision can help show whether unsafe practices, defective equipment, or missing safeguards contributed to the incident. In many construction cases, multiple parties may share responsibility, and liability is assessed on the basis of comparative fault principles where applicable. Investigations often look at who controlled the work, who provided equipment or safety devices, and whether those parties followed required protocols. Establishing fault may also involve technical review of equipment performance or site conditions, and when necessary medical and reconstruction opinions can explain how the injury occurred and who bore responsibility for maintaining a safe work environment.
Reporting an accident to OSHA can prompt an inspection that documents unsafe conditions and may result in citations if safety violations are found, and those findings can be useful when assembling evidence for a claim. OSHA records of inspections, violations, and corrective actions provide an independent source of information about site safety that can support claims showing lapses in required practices. While OSHA enforcement is separate from civil claims, its records can corroborate allegations about dangerous conditions that contributed to an injury. Filing an OSHA complaint should be considered when there are apparent safety violations that pose an ongoing risk, and the process can complement civil or administrative claims by creating an official record of hazards. Be mindful of reporting timelines and confidentiality concerns, and retain copies of any OSHA communications or inspection reports to include with other documentation of the incident.
Many law firms handle construction injury matters on a contingency fee basis, which means fees are typically tied to a portion of any recovery rather than charged up front, and this arrangement helps injured people pursue claims without immediate out-of-pocket legal expenses. Specific fee structures and how costs are handled can vary, so it is important to get a clear written explanation of the fee agreement, how expenses such as expert fees or court costs will be advanced, and whether repayment obligations arise only from recoveries obtained on your behalf. Understanding the fee agreement helps set expectations about timing, the possible net recovery after fees and expenses, and how settlement offers will be evaluated. Before moving forward, request a plain-language summary of anticipated costs and communication protocols so that decision-making about settlements or litigation is informed by a transparent view of financial responsibilities and likely outcomes.
Explore our injury practice areas
⚖️ All Personal Injury Services