Crane collapses are catastrophic events that can cause life changing injuries, property loss, and complex liability questions for people in Greenpoint and greater Kings County. When a crane or lifting device fails, victims may face mounting medical bills, loss of income, and long recovery times while multiple parties investigate and assign blame. The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC, led by Allan J. Ahearne, Jr., represents individuals and families affected by these incidents, helping them understand their rights and options under New York law. If you or a loved one were hurt in a crane collapse, prompt action to document injuries and preserve evidence can be essential to protecting recovery options.
Pursuing a legal claim after a crane collapse helps injured people obtain compensation for medical care, lost wages, pain and suffering, and ongoing needs related to the injury. Legal action facilitates formal evidence gathering, including inspections and expert analysis, to establish how the collapse happened and who should be held responsible. It also provides a structured path to negotiate with insurance companies and other parties who may minimize claims. By pursuing a claim thoughtfully, victims and their families can secure resources to cover long-term care, rehabilitation, and adjustments needed to maintain quality of life following a severe accident.
Negligence is the legal concept used to describe conduct that falls short of the standard of care expected under the circumstances and that causes harm to another person. In a crane collapse context, negligence can include failure to inspect equipment, inadequate training for operators, ignoring safety protocols, or improper setup of the crane. To prove negligence, a claimant generally shows that a duty existed, that the duty was breached, that the breach caused the injury, and that damages resulted. Establishing these elements often requires factual investigation, documentary proof, and testimony from witnesses.
Workers’ compensation is a state-mandated insurance system designed to provide medical care and wage replacement for employees injured on the job, regardless of fault. When a crane collapse injures an employee, workers’ compensation benefits may cover many treatment costs and a portion of lost earnings, but those benefits do not always compensate for pain and suffering or losses from third-party negligence. In such situations, injured workers may have the ability to pursue a separate third-party claim against responsible contractors, equipment manufacturers, or property owners in addition to collecting workers’ compensation benefits.
Liability insurance is coverage carried by contractors, owners, and other parties to protect against claims arising from injury or property damage. After a crane collapse, liability insurance policies are often the primary source for compensating victims, but insurers may dispute coverage or the size of a claim. Understanding policy limits, coverage terms, and which insurer is responsible can be complex, particularly when multiple policies or parties are involved. Careful handling of notice requirements and deadlines is important to preserve recovery options under applicable insurance contracts.
OSHA refers to federal and state occupational safety rules that govern workplace practices, including crane operation, inspection, and maintenance standards. Violations of safety regulations can be evidence in a civil claim to show unsafe conditions or practices, though enforcement actions and civil liability are distinct processes. Regulatory reports, citations, and investigation findings may support a claim by documenting lapses in safety procedures. An investigation into a collapse often includes reviewing whether applicable OSHA standards and industry guidelines were followed and whether those failures contributed to the incident.
After a crane collapse, take steps to preserve physical evidence and scene information whenever it is safe to do so, including taking photographs of the site, damaged equipment, and any visible injuries. Collect contact information for witnesses and obtain copies of any incident reports completed by on‑site supervisors or safety officers, as those records may be critical when reconstructing events. Prompt preservation of evidence helps ensure that inspectors, investigators, and legal counsel can build a clear picture of what occurred and how responsibility should be allocated.
Keep detailed records of medical visits, diagnoses, treatment plans, prescriptions, and any therapy appointments related to injuries from the collapse, as this documentation is central to proving the extent of harm and care needs. Save all receipts for medical expenses, transportation, home modifications, or assistive devices, and track time missed from work along with any lost income. Thorough documentation of injuries and expenses allows a clearer calculation of damages and supports discussions with insurers or opposing parties about appropriate compensation.
Insurance companies may present settlement offers early in a case before the full scope of injuries and future costs are known; carefully consider such offers and avoid accepting payment without understanding long term implications. Accepting an early offer can waive rights to later compensation for ongoing care or complications that emerge as recovery progresses. Seeking guidance and ensuring that offers reflect both current and anticipated needs helps protect long term financial stability and ensures that settlement decisions are informed and appropriate.
Comprehensive legal representation is often warranted when multiple contractors, subcontractors, equipment owners, and manufacturers may share responsibility for a collapse, creating complex fault issues and overlapping insurance coverage. In those scenarios, thorough investigation including accident reconstruction, inspection of maintenance records, and coordination with technical consultants is typically needed to determine causation and identify all potentially liable parties. Full representation helps manage the procedural demands of dealing with numerous defendants and insurers while pursuing a recovery that reflects the full scope of the victim’s losses.
When an injured person suffers catastrophic harm, such as traumatic brain injury, spine damage, or loss of limb function, comprehensive representation is often necessary to secure compensation that addresses long term medical needs, rehabilitation, adaptive equipment, and loss of earning capacity. Building a claim in these cases requires careful coordination with medical professionals and vocational specialists to establish future care needs and economic impact. Full representation focuses on developing a claim that accounts for ongoing treatment, supportive services, and life care planning so future needs are considered in settlement or litigation.
A more limited approach may be appropriate when liability is straightforward, only one party is clearly at fault, and injuries are relatively minor and expected to resolve quickly with routine care. In such cases, focused negotiation with the responsible insurer and accurate documentation of expenses and recovery may lead to an efficient settlement without protracted litigation. Even in simpler matters, careful documentation of medical treatment and economic losses remains important to ensure any settlement fairly compensates for actual damages.
When an injured worker’s situation is clearly covered by workers’ compensation and the available benefits meet medical and wage needs, pursuing only those benefits may be sufficient, though it is still important to evaluate potential third‑party claims for losses not covered by the work comp system. In scenarios where the employer’s insurer or the work comp program provides adequate coverage for ongoing care, a narrower legal approach focused on benefits collection can streamline the recovery process. An assessment of both workers’ compensation and third‑party options helps determine the appropriate path.
Crane collapses frequently happen at construction sites where heavy loads are lifted near workers and the public, making site conditions, load calculations, and operator practices central to determining responsibility and the scope of harm suffered. A careful review of safety plans, permits, site supervision, and adherence to industry standards is often necessary to demonstrate how a collapse occurred and who may bear responsibility for resulting injuries.
Mechanical failure or defective crane components, including breakage of structural parts, faulty hoisting equipment, or malfunctioning safety devices, can directly lead to a collapse and form the basis for claims against manufacturers or maintenance providers. Investigation of maintenance logs, recall history, and repair records helps establish whether equipment failure played a central role in causing injuries and losses.
Improper rigging, incorrect load ratings, unstable ground conditions, or overloading of the crane are common factors behind collapses and can implicate companies responsible for planning, supervision, and site preparation. Demonstrating that safe rigging practices or load limits were ignored is often critical to holding those parties accountable for harm to workers and bystanders.
The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC handles serious personal injury matters arising from construction accidents and crane collapses in Greenpoint and the surrounding New York communities. Attorney Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. leads investigations, coordinates with medical providers and technical consultants, and communicates regularly with clients about case progress. The firm is committed to clear client communication and thorough preparation, working to identify all potentially responsible parties and applicable insurance coverage so that each claim seeks compensation that reflects the injury’s full impact on a client’s life and finances.
Immediately after a crane collapse causes injury, prioritize safety and medical care by seeking emergency treatment for anyone injured and ensuring the site is as safe as possible. When it is safe to do so, document the scene with photographs or video, gather contact information for witnesses, and preserve records such as incident reports or supervisor statements. These actions help protect health and create an initial record that will be useful in any later investigation or claim. After addressing immediate safety and medical needs, notify your insurer and consider contacting legal counsel to discuss next steps and preserve legal rights. Early involvement of legal counsel can assist in obtaining and securing vital evidence like maintenance logs and inspection reports, coordinating medical documentation, and advising on communications with insurers and other parties to avoid inadvertent statements that could affect a claim.
Responsibility for a crane collapse can rest with a range of parties, depending on the facts, including the equipment owner, the company operating the crane, subcontractors on site, the party responsible for rigging, and manufacturers of defective parts. Determining liability often requires reviewing contracts, maintenance records, and operator credentials to see which party had responsibility for inspection, operation, and safe setup of the crane. In some incidents, multiple parties may share liability, and insurance coverage may be spread across different carriers. Establishing fault may require technical investigation by engineers and reviews of inspection history, training records, and safety procedures to determine whether negligence or defective equipment contributed to the collapse and consequent injuries.
Workers’ compensation typically provides medical and wage benefits to employees injured on the job regardless of fault, and most injured workers will be entitled to these benefits after a crane collapse at the workplace. Because workers’ compensation normally excludes pain and suffering damages, injured employees may also have the right to pursue a separate third‑party claim against other responsible entities whose negligence caused the collapse, such as equipment manufacturers or negligent contractors. Pursuing a third‑party claim does not usually prevent a worker from collecting workers’ compensation benefits, but careful coordination is essential to avoid conflicts and to ensure proper allocation of any recovery. Consulting with legal counsel helps to evaluate the potential for a third‑party claim and to navigate the interactions between workers’ compensation benefits and other avenues for recovery.
Damages in a crane collapse claim can include past and future medical expenses, lost wages and diminished earning capacity, pain and suffering, and compensation for permanent impairment or loss of enjoyment of life. When appropriate, claims may also seek recovery for rehabilitation costs, home modifications, assistive devices, and the value of household services lost due to the injury. The specific damages available depend on the nature of the injury and the applicable legal framework governing the claim. Accurately quantifying damages requires documentation of medical care, economic losses, and non‑economic harms, often supported by medical and vocational evaluations. A well‑developed claim considers both current expenses and anticipated future needs to ensure that any recovery addresses the full, long term impact of the injury on the victim and their family.
The time required to resolve a crane collapse claim varies significantly based on the complexity of liability, severity of injuries, number of parties involved, and whether the case settles or proceeds to trial. Some claims with clear liability and modest injuries may resolve in a matter of months through negotiation, while complex claims involving technical investigations, disputed causation, or catastrophic injuries can take a year or more to conclude when litigation and appeals are involved. Resolving a case efficiently often depends on how quickly medical treatment and documentation progress, the speed of obtaining relevant records and reports, and the willingness of insurers or parties to negotiate in good faith. Keeping detailed records and maintaining open communication with counsel can help move a claim forward while protecting the claimant’s interests.
New York follows comparative negligence rules, which generally allow injured people to recover damages even if they were partially at fault, with any award reduced proportionally to their share of responsibility. If an injured person bears some fault for the accident, the claim can still proceed, but the final recovery may be reduced to reflect that percentage of fault. Assessing fault percentages requires careful analysis of the facts and evidence in each case. Even when partial fault exists, pursuing a claim may be important to cover medical costs and other losses that exceed available benefits. Legal counsel can assist in presenting evidence that minimizes the claimant’s percentage of fault and demonstrates the primary responsible parties for the collapse.
Yes, site inspections, maintenance records, inspection logs, and operator training documentation are frequently central to proving how a crane collapse occurred and which parties were responsible. These materials can show whether required safety checks were performed, whether maintenance was timely, and whether operators were properly trained, all of which inform liability determinations. Accident scene photographs and witness statements also play a key role in reconstructing events and supporting a claim. Preserving such evidence promptly is important because records can be altered or lost over time and physical conditions at the scene may change. Engaging counsel early helps ensure that subpoenas, preservation letters, and other protective steps are taken to secure critical information for use in settlement talks or litigation.
A lawsuit is sometimes necessary to obtain full and fair compensation, especially when insurers deny liability, offer inadequate settlements, or when multiple parties and coverage issues must be resolved through formal legal processes. Filing a lawsuit also allows a claimant to request discovery of records and compel testimony to build a stronger case. In many matters, filing a complaint is a step to preserve legal rights while negotiations continue. However, not every claim requires litigation; many cases are resolved through negotiation and settlement without court filings when responsibility is clear and parties are willing to agree on fair terms. The decision to file depends on case specifics and the claimant’s goals, and counsel can advise on the likelihood of resolving the matter without litigation versus the need to proceed to court.
Medical expenses and future care needs are evaluated through detailed review of medical records, treatment plans, and opinions from treating providers about prognosis and likely future treatment, including surgeries, therapies, medications, and assistive devices. When injuries have long term or permanent effects, life care planning or vocational assessments may be used to estimate the cost of ongoing care, loss of earning capacity, and adaptive modifications to the home or vehicle. Accurate evaluation also considers current out of pocket costs, anticipated future medical needs, and the economic impact of lost wages and reduced earning ability. Presenting a clear, well‑documented picture of both present and future needs is essential to negotiating or litigating for compensation that addresses the full scope of a claimant’s losses.
The most important evidence to preserve after a crane collapse includes photographs and videos of the scene, damaged equipment, and visible injuries, witness contact information and statements, maintenance and inspection records for the crane, operator training documentation, and any incident or accident reports prepared by on‑site personnel. These materials form the factual foundation for proving how the collapse occurred and who should be held responsible for resulting injuries and losses. Additionally, preserving medical records, receipts for expenses, and records of lost income is critical to establishing the damages sustained. Acting quickly to secure and copy relevant documents and to memorialize witness accounts helps ensure that essential evidence remains available for investigation, negotiation, or litigation.
Explore our injury practice areas
⚖️ All Personal Injury Services