Traumatic brain injuries can change a life in an instant, and families in Sunset Park need clear information about their legal options when such harm occurs. This page explains how a personal injury claim for TBI typically moves from the initial medical evaluation through investigation, evidence gathering, and negotiations or litigation. The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC and Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. represent people injured in Kings County and throughout New York, helping clients understand deadlines, liability issues, and how damages are calculated. If you or a loved one suffered a head injury, this guide is intended to clarify the process and next steps.
After a traumatic brain injury, prompt and well-organized legal action can protect medical benefits, help preserve evidence, and support a claim for compensation that reflects the full scope of your losses. Legal involvement helps ensure that insurance companies and other parties do not minimize symptoms or shift blame, and it creates a coordinated approach to gathering medical records, witness statements, and expert reports when needed. For families, having legal guidance can reduce administrative burdens so they can focus on recovery and care. The right legal approach aims to recover compensation for medical expenses, lost income, ongoing care needs, and the non-economic impacts such as pain and reduced quality of life.
A traumatic brain injury is an injury to the brain caused by an external force, such as a blow to the head, rapid acceleration-deceleration, or penetration. TBIs range from mild concussions to severe injuries that result in long-term impairment of cognitive, sensory, motor, or emotional functioning. Medical diagnosis relies on clinical assessment, imaging like CT or MRI scans, and sometimes neuropsychological testing to evaluate cognitive deficits. For legal claims, documentation of the event, timely medical treatment, and ongoing records that track changes over time are essential to support a claim for damages related to the injury.
Post-concussive symptoms refer to a range of ongoing physical, cognitive, and emotional effects that can follow a concussion or milder traumatic brain injury. Symptoms may include headaches, memory problems, difficulty concentrating, sleep disturbances, mood changes, and sensitivity to noise or light. While some people recover within weeks, others experience persistent symptoms that interfere with daily activities and work. Detailed medical records and symptom logs are important for documenting ongoing impairment and demonstrating the impact on life and earning capacity when pursuing compensation.
Negligence is the legal concept used to hold a person or entity responsible when they fail to act with reasonable care and that failure causes harm. In the context of TBI, negligence can arise from distracted driving, unsafe property conditions, inadequate safety protocols at a workplace, or other preventable actions. A negligence claim typically requires showing that the responsible party had a duty of care, breached that duty, and that breach caused the injury and resulting damages. Evidence of negligent conduct, such as police reports, maintenance records, or witness statements, is often central to a case.
Damages are the monetary compensation pursued in a legal claim to address losses caused by an injury. For traumatic brain injury cases, damages can include past and future medical expenses, rehabilitation, lost income, diminished earning capacity, and compensation for pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life. Calculating damages often requires input from medical providers, vocational analysts, and life care planners to estimate ongoing care needs and economic impact. Clear documentation of expenses and the injury’s effect on daily functioning supports a claim for appropriate compensation.
Begin a thorough record of medical visits, symptoms, and conversations about your condition as soon as possible after the injury. Include dates, names of providers, test results, and a daily symptom journal to show the course and persistence of impairments. Consistent documentation strengthens a claim by creating a clear timeline that links the incident to ongoing medical needs and effects on daily life.
Save any physical evidence and make note of witnesses who observed the incident or subsequent changes in your condition. Photographs of the scene, safety conditions, and injuries taken soon after the event can be invaluable, as can contact information for witnesses who can describe what they saw. Early preservation of evidence reduces the risk that important details are lost and helps investigators reconstruct how the injury occurred.
Keep your medical care providers informed about symptoms and treatment progress and follow recommended rehabilitation plans to document ongoing needs. Communicate openly with your legal representative so they can request records and consult medical specialists when necessary to articulate future care requirements. A coordinated approach ensures medical findings and legal claims align, which supports a more accurate assessment of damages and recovery needs.
When medical treatment extends over months or years and care needs are ongoing, a comprehensive approach helps quantify future costs and coordinate expert input to project long-term expenses. This approach gathers medical, vocational, and life-care planning information to establish a realistic picture of future needs. It is important when a single settlement must address decades of care and lost earning capacity.
A comprehensive approach is often needed when liability is contested or more than one party may share responsibility, since it involves a deeper factual investigation and potential coordination among claims. Gathering documentary evidence, retaining specialists to explain causation, and preparing for litigation preserves options if settlement talks do not resolve the case. This pathway can be time-intensive but helps ensure all responsible parties are pursued for appropriate compensation.
If a head injury is mild and the injured person returns to normal activities quickly with minimal medical costs, a limited approach focused on a prompt insurance claim may be appropriate. This path may prioritize swift negotiation for medical bills and short-term wage loss without extensive expert involvement. It is suitable when the clinical course is uncomplicated and there is little likelihood of long-term impairment.
When the at-fault party’s responsibility is undisputed and damages are primarily limited to documented, immediate expenses, a focused claim may resolve matters efficiently. Negotiation with the insurer to cover known bills and a short period of lost wages can avoid drawn-out procedures. This option reduces time spent on litigation while still addressing tangible financial losses for the injured person.
Car and truck collisions often cause head injuries from impact or rapid movement of the head, requiring prompt medical evaluation and documentation to link the crash to lasting symptoms. Insurance investigations are common after collisions, so preserving evidence and reporting symptoms early supports a stronger claim.
Falls on unsafe property surfaces or poorly maintained public spaces can produce traumatic brain injuries, and establishing property owner responsibility depends on demonstrating a hazardous condition and notice or reason to know about it. Photographs of the hazard and witness statements are useful to show how the incident occurred.
Work-related head injuries or assaults may give rise to workers’ compensation claims as well as third-party claims when a non-employer party is at fault, and coordinating those claims can be important for maximizing recovery. Timely reporting to supervisors and documenting the event supports both medical care and legal options.
Ahearne Law Firm PLLC brings local New York practice knowledge to traumatic brain injury matters in Kings County, ensuring cases are handled with attention to medical detail and procedural deadlines. Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. works directly with clients to request medical records, obtain necessary documentation, and communicate with insurers on behalf of injured people and families. The firm focuses on building a comprehensive record of the injury and its consequences so that settlement discussions or courtroom advocacy reflect the full scope of loss and future needs.
If you suspect a traumatic brain injury, seek medical attention immediately, even if symptoms seem mild at first, because some effects can be delayed and early evaluation helps establish a clear record. Document the incident by noting where and when it occurred and preserving any evidence such as clothing or photos. Notify appropriate authorities or property managers when applicable, and obtain contact information for witnesses to the event. After obtaining medical care, keep thorough records of all treatments, follow-up visits, and symptoms, and maintain a daily log of how the injury affects concentration, memory, mood, sleep, and daily activities. Avoid giving detailed statements to insurers before consulting with a legal professional and instead focus on completing medical assessments and preserving evidence so your legal team can evaluate the full scope of the claim and advise on next steps.
Liability in a traumatic brain injury claim is established by showing that another party had a duty to act reasonably, breached that duty, and that breach caused the injury and resulting damages. Evidence may include accident reports, surveillance footage, maintenance logs, witness statements, and expert opinions that link negligent conduct to the injury. Careful investigation is necessary to trace how the incident happened and to identify responsible parties. When multiple parties might share responsibility, the legal process examines each party’s conduct and degree of fault. Comparative fault rules in New York can affect recovery if the injured person shares some responsibility, so documenting the circumstances and sequence of events is important to minimize disputes about causation and to support the strongest possible claim for compensation.
Damages in a TBI case typically include past and future medical expenses for hospital care, surgeries, rehabilitation, medication, and assistive devices needed due to the injury. Economic damages also cover past and future lost earnings and diminished earning capacity when the injury affects the person’s ability to work. Organizing bills, pay stubs, and prognoses from treating providers helps quantify economic losses. Non-economic damages compensate for pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and diminished ability to participate in family and social activities. In more severe cases, damages can also include the cost of long-term care and home modifications. Demonstrating the daily impact of the injury through caregiver statements, therapy reports, and medical evaluations supports a comprehensive damages claim.
New York’s statute of limitations for most personal injury claims generally requires a lawsuit to be filed within three years from the date of the injury, though exceptions and different time limits can apply depending on the circumstances. It is important to act early because deadlines for notifying certain defendants or governmental entities may be shorter, and waiting too long can bar recovery. Timely action also preserves evidence and witness recollections that can fade over time. If you are unsure about how the time limits apply to your situation, consult with a law firm promptly to evaluate deadlines and preserve your rights. Early consultation allows the firm to collect records, send timely demands, and prepare filings if litigation becomes necessary, reducing the risk that procedural issues will prevent you from pursuing compensation.
Many traumatic brain injury claims are resolved through negotiation with insurance carriers and opposing counsel, especially when liability is clear and damages can be reasonably quantified. Settlement can provide a faster resolution without the uncertainty and exposure of a trial, and negotiations often involve demonstrating the medical record, projected care needs, and documented losses to reach a fair resolution. Insurance adjusters may engage in multiple rounds of negotiation before arriving at a final settlement. When liability is disputed, damages are contested, or a satisfactory settlement cannot be reached, litigation may be necessary to pursue full recovery. Preparing for trial requires a higher level of investigation and proof, including expert testimony and comprehensive medical and vocational documentation. Whether a case proceeds to trial or settles depends on the strength of the evidence, the willingness of parties to negotiate, and the best interests of the injured person.
Medical records and diagnostic testing form the backbone of most TBI claims because they document the initial injury, the course of treatment, and any ongoing deficits that affect daily life. Imaging studies, clinical notes, therapy records, and neuropsychological testing provide objective and subjective evidence of the injury and its impact. Maintaining continuity of care and following recommended treatments creates a record that supports claims for future care and rehabilitation needs. When imaging is inconclusive, detailed clinical notes and neurocognitive testing can still substantiate ongoing impairments that affect work and daily functioning. Collaborating with treating providers to obtain thorough reports and, when necessary, arranging independent medical consultations helps clarify prognosis and support calculations for future medical and related costs in settlement or trial preparation.
Witnesses and photographs help reconstruct how an incident occurred and can corroborate accounts of the event, seating positions, road conditions, property hazards, or immediate symptoms after the injury. Witness statements taken while memories are fresh and photos of the scene and injuries provide tangible context for claims, which can be persuasive to insurers or juries when combined with medical evidence. Collecting names and contact details at the outset is valuable for later investigation. Detailed visual documentation of the scene, safety conditions, and visible injuries supports the factual narrative and helps demonstrate negligence or unsafe conditions. When witness memory fades or conditions change, photographic and written documentation preserved early on can be among the most reliable forms of evidence to support a claim for compensation.
New York follows a comparative negligence rule that allows recovery even if the injured person is partially at fault, but the recovery amount may be reduced in proportion to the person’s degree of fault. Establishing the relative responsibility of all parties requires careful factual development, and strategies focus on minimizing perceived fault through witness accounts, expert reconstruction, and documentation that clarifies the incident. Demonstrating that the other party bore greater responsibility supports a stronger recovery. Even if partial fault may be raised by the other side, pursuing a claim can still be worthwhile when damages are significant. Legal counsel can evaluate how comparative fault rules might affect potential recovery and advise on steps to preserve evidence and present a narrative that fairly assigns responsibility to the appropriate parties.
Calculating future care costs and lost earning capacity involves combining medical prognoses with vocational and life-care assessments to estimate ongoing medical, rehabilitation, and support needs, as well as potential reductions in employment ability. Treating providers, physical and occupational therapists, and life-care planners can help project long-term needs, while vocational specialists estimate the effect of injuries on job prospects and earning potential. These combined inputs create a comprehensive picture of future economic losses. Courts and insurers consider documented medical needs, expert projections, and evidence of pre-injury employment and earning history when assessing future damages. Presenting thorough documentation that ties the injury to anticipated care needs and lost income helps justify compensation that covers both current and future economic impacts on the injured person and their family.
Ahearne Law Firm PLLC assists clients by gathering medical records, requesting relevant documentation, and coordinating with medical providers to document the injury and its consequences. The firm helps preserve evidence, identify responsible parties, and present compelling records to insurers or in court. Through clear communication and managed deadlines, the firm aims to reduce the administrative burden on injured people and their families while pursuing an appropriate recovery for medical costs and related losses. The firm will evaluate options for negotiation and litigation based on the specifics of the case, work with medical and vocational professionals to quantify damage, and advise on settlement offers versus trial. Clients receive guidance tailored to their circumstances, including next steps for medical follow-up, evidence preservation, and the timeline for a potential legal resolution, so they can make informed decisions during recovery.
Explore our injury practice areas
⚖️ All Personal Injury Services