Traumatic brain injuries (TBI) can have life-altering effects on a person and their family, and residents of Addison and surrounding Steuben County deserve clear information about their legal options. This guide explains how a personal injury claim for a TBI is typically handled in New York, what steps to take after an injury, and how the Ahearne Law Firm PLLC can assist in gathering medical records, identifying responsible parties, and pursuing fair recovery. If you or a loved one sustained a head injury, seeking timely legal information and preserving documentation can make a meaningful difference in your case outcome and long-term care planning.
Legal representation in a traumatic brain injury claim can bring several practical benefits that help injured people pursue meaningful recovery. An attorney can help assemble and preserve medical records, coordinate with treating providers for clear documentation of symptoms and prognosis, and identify all potentially responsible parties beyond the most obvious source of harm. Representation also supports preparation of a claim value that considers future care, lost earning capacity, and non-economic losses. By managing communications with insurers and opposing parties, a lawyer gives the injured person space to focus on medical care and rehabilitation while ensuring procedural deadlines and evidentiary needs are addressed.
A traumatic brain injury occurs when an external force causes damage to the brain, which may lead to temporary or permanent changes in function. TBIs range from mild concussions to severe injuries that require long-term medical care and rehabilitation. Symptoms may include headaches, memory loss, difficulty concentrating, mood changes, sensory disturbances, and physical impairment. Legal claims for TBI focus not only on the immediate medical treatment but also on the long-term needs for therapy, assistive services, and possible impacts on employment and daily living. Documentation of diagnosis and ongoing treatment is important in proving the nature and extent of the injury.
A concussion is a form of mild traumatic brain injury resulting from a blow or jolt to the head that temporarily affects brain function. Symptoms can include dizziness, confusion, memory lapses, and sensitivity to light or noise; these may appear immediately or develop over time. While many concussions resolve with rest and proper medical care, some individuals experience prolonged symptoms requiring further treatment. In legal claims, a documented concussion can support an injury case when linked to the incident and to ongoing medical care, and records should capture initial evaluations, follow-up visits, and any recommended therapies.
Negligence is the legal concept used to hold a party responsible when their failure to act with reasonable care causes harm to another person. In a TBI claim, showing negligence generally requires proving that the defendant owed the injured person a duty of care, that the defendant breached that duty by acting or failing to act carelessly, and that this breach caused the brain injury and resulting damages. Evidence might include witness statements, surveillance or accident reports, maintenance records, and expert medical testimony linking the defendant’s conduct to the injury and losses sustained by the victim.
Damages refer to the monetary compensation sought by an injured person to address losses caused by another party’s wrongful conduct. In TBI claims, damages commonly include past and future medical expenses, lost wages and diminished earning capacity, the cost of ongoing care and assistive services, and compensation for pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life. Calculating damages often requires medical evidence, vocational assessments, and consideration of how the injury affects daily functioning and long-term prospects. Accurate documentation and realistic valuation of future needs are essential to pursue adequate recovery.
After any head trauma, seek immediate medical attention even if symptoms seem mild, because some signs of a brain injury can develop gradually and might not be obvious initially. Early documentation of symptoms, diagnostic imaging, and physician evaluations establish a medical record that links the incident to the injury and supports any later legal claim. Prompt care also helps the injured person receive appropriate treatment and create a timeline that is useful when discussing the case with insurers or legal counsel.
Keep comprehensive records of all medical visits, treatments, medications, therapy sessions, and any out-of-pocket expenses related to the injury; this documentation is central to proving damages in a TBI claim. Maintain a journal describing symptoms, changes in daily functioning, and any limitations at home or work, as these firsthand notes can supplement medical records when describing non-economic impacts. Accurate records also assist in calculating future care needs and lost earning capacity, and they make it easier for legal counsel to evaluate the claim and communicate effectively with insurers.
Preserve physical evidence, photos of the scene, equipment involved, and any clothing or personal items connected to the incident, as these items can help establish fault and the mechanism of injury. Collect contact information for witnesses and make notes about what they observed, because witness statements can corroborate the sequence of events and the severity of the incident. Timely preservation of evidence and witness details strengthens the factual record and supports a more thorough investigation of potential liability.
Comprehensive legal representation is often appropriate when a brain injury causes significant, ongoing medical needs or long-term impairments that affect employment and daily life. In such cases, calculating damages requires projecting future care costs, therapy, and potential lost earning capacity, which involves coordination with medical and vocational providers to create a thorough valuation. A full-service approach can include detailed investigation, retention of medical professionals for testimony, and preparation for trial if settlement negotiations do not adequately address future needs and losses.
A comprehensive approach is also important when liability is contested or there are multiple parties potentially responsible for the injury, such as employers, manufacturers, or property owners. Complex legal scenarios require careful evidence gathering, analysis of safety records, and possibly reconstruction of events to establish causation and fault. Thorough representation helps ensure all responsible parties are identified and that settlement offers account for present and future losses, while preserving the option to pursue litigation when necessary to achieve fair compensation.
A more limited legal approach may be appropriate when the injury resulted in short-term symptoms that resolved quickly and where medical treatment was minimal. In those cases, a focused effort to document medical visits, confirm recovery, and negotiate with the insurer may be sufficient to resolve the matter without extensive litigation. Still, it is important to ensure all medical documentation is complete and to consider potential delayed symptoms before accepting any final settlement offers.
When fault is clear and the economic and non-economic losses are modest, a limited approach to resolution may be reasonable, focusing on efficient negotiations to recover medical bills and short-term losses. This path can spare the injured party protracted legal proceedings and reduce costs when the likely recovery is straightforward. Even in these situations, careful documentation and an understanding of settlement value are important to avoid accepting an offer that does not fully cover recovery-related expenses.
Motor vehicle collisions are a frequent source of traumatic brain injuries when occupants experience sudden impact, rapid acceleration-deceleration, or head contact with interior surfaces. Evidence from police reports, vehicle damage assessments, medical records, and witness accounts is often important to link the crash mechanics to the injury and establish liability for compensation.
Workplace incidents, including falls from heights, struck-by events, and machinery accidents, can cause brain injuries that require both immediate medical care and potential claims against employers or third parties. Investigation of safety records, incident reports, and co-worker statements can be necessary to identify responsible parties and pursue recovery for medical and related losses.
Slip and fall events on improperly maintained property can produce head trauma, especially when a fall results in blunt force to the skull or brain. Documentation of the hazard, maintenance logs, witness statements, and timely medical evaluation help establish the connection between the hazardous condition and the resulting injury.
Ahearne Law Firm PLLC focuses on helping people in the Hudson Valley and surrounding regions address the legal and practical challenges that follow a traumatic brain injury. The firm assists clients with preserving evidence, collecting medical documentation, assessing current and future care needs, and communicating with insurers to pursue fair compensation. Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. provides direct attention to each case and works with medical and vocational professionals when necessary to develop a clear, documented valuation of damages that reflects both present and anticipated needs.
A traumatic brain injury (TBI) is an injury to the brain caused by an external force such as a blow, jolt, or penetrating injury to the head that results in functional impairment. TBIs have a wide range of severity, from mild concussions with temporary symptoms to severe injuries that produce long-term cognitive, physical, and emotional impairment. Symptoms can include headaches, memory problems, dizziness, concentration difficulties, mood changes, sensory issues, and disruptions in sleep, and some symptoms may not be immediately apparent without medical evaluation. For legal purposes, documentation of the injury and its connection to a specific incident is essential. Medical records, diagnostic imaging, and physician notes that link the event to ongoing symptoms help establish the factual basis of a claim. The legal process will evaluate causation, the defendant’s responsibility, and the nature of damages caused by the injury, so early medical attention and thorough records improve the ability to pursue compensation.
In New York, the statute of limitations for most personal injury claims, including many traumatic brain injury cases, is generally two years from the date of the injury. This deadline means a lawsuit must typically be filed within that period or the injured person may lose the right to pursue civil compensation through the courts. There are limited exceptions and special rules that can alter the deadline depending on the circumstances, such as claims against certain government entities or situations involving delayed discovery of injury symptoms. Because deadlines vary and exceptions may apply, it is important to seek advice and begin preserving evidence as soon as possible after a brain injury. Even before filing a lawsuit, taking timely action to collect medical records, witness statements, and documentation of lost earnings helps protect legal rights and supports any eventual claim or negotiation with insurers.
Damages in a brain injury case aim to compensate the injured person for losses caused by another party’s wrongful conduct. Recoverable economic damages commonly include past and future medical expenses, the cost of rehabilitation and assistive care, lost wages, and diminished earning capacity when the injury affects the ability to work. Non-economic damages may cover pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and emotional distress connected to the injury and its long-term effects. In some cases, punitive damages may be available when a defendant’s conduct was particularly reckless or intentional, but these are not common and depend on the specifics of the incident and legal standards. Calculating damages for a TBI often requires input from medical providers, life-care planners, and vocational professionals to estimate ongoing needs and the financial impact over time.
Negligence is the legal theory most often used to pursue compensation in a TBI claim, and it requires showing that the defendant owed a duty of care, the duty was breached, and that breach caused the injury and resulting damages. Establishing negligence typically relies on evidence such as witness statements, surveillance footage, incident or police reports, safety and maintenance records, and medical documentation that ties the event to the brain injury. The process evaluates whether the defendant acted reasonably under the circumstances and whether that conduct led to harm. New York follows comparative fault rules, which means that if the injured person shares some responsibility for the incident, the amount of recovery may be reduced proportionally. Understanding how negligence and comparative fault apply to a specific case requires careful review of the facts, and timely investigation helps clarify responsibility and evidence needed to support the claim.
It is generally advisable to be cautious when speaking with insurance adjusters after a brain injury, because initial statements or recorded conversations can be used to minimize the value of a claim. Insurers may seek to obtain a quick recorded statement or details that appear to reduce the severity of the injury, and without full medical documentation it can be difficult to convey the long-term impact of a TBI. If you do communicate with an insurer, keep remarks factual and avoid speculation about the cause or extent of your symptoms. Consulting with legal counsel before giving detailed statements or signing releases can help protect your rights and ensure that communications do not unintentionally harm your claim. A lawyer can handle insurer communications, advise whether to provide specific information, and ensure medical records and evidence are presented appropriately when negotiating for a resolution.
Important medical records for a TBI claim include emergency room records, hospital discharge summaries, imaging reports such as CT or MRI scans, neurology consultations, rehabilitation and therapy notes, and records of follow-up visits with primary care or specialists. These documents show the medical observations, diagnostic findings, treatments provided, and recommendations for ongoing care, all of which are essential for proving the nature and extent of the injury. Records that document functional limitations, cognitive testing, and therapy progress are also useful when assessing long-term needs. Maintaining a timeline of care and obtaining copies of billing statements and receipts for related expenses further supports the economic portion of a claim. If care is ongoing, continued documentation of treatments and medical recommendations will help calculate future costs, and timely collection of these records enables a more accurate evaluation of damages for negotiations or, if necessary, litigation.
Yes, you can often pursue a TBI claim even if you were partially at fault, because New York uses a comparative fault system that reduces recovery in proportion to your share of responsibility rather than barring recovery entirely. For example, if a jury finds you 20 percent at fault and total damages are calculated at a certain amount, your recoverable compensation would typically be reduced by your percentage of fault. Establishing the relative degree of fault requires evidence that clarifies how the incident occurred and the actions of all involved parties. It is important to develop a strong factual record showing the other party’s role in causing the injury and any factors that mitigate your responsibility. Witness statements, accident reports, photographic or video evidence, and expert analysis of the incident can all affect fault allocation, and prompt investigation helps ensure relevant evidence is preserved and presented effectively.
The length of a brain injury case varies significantly based on factors such as the severity of the injury, the complexity of liability, the need for future care projections, and whether the case resolves through negotiation or proceeds to trial. Some cases with straightforward liability and limited damages may settle within months, while more serious matters involving ongoing treatment, disputed causation, or contested damages can take a year or several years to resolve. The process includes investigation, discovery, and possible pretrial motions or settlement discussions, all of which affect timing. Recovery timelines also depend on how long medical providers need to evaluate the extent of recovery and the appropriate prognosis. Parties often wait until the injured person reaches a stable medical condition before finalizing significant claims for future needs, which can extend case duration but helps ensure a fuller account of damages is considered in settlement or trial.
If the responsible party has limited insurance coverage, options may include pursuing an uninsured or underinsured motorist claim if applicable, seeking recovery from additional responsible parties, or exploring other available sources such as employer liability or product liability depending on the circumstances. A careful review of all potential defendants and insurance policies is necessary to identify where available recovery funds may exist. In some cases, creative approaches such as structured settlements or negotiating with the insured party’s carrier can help maximize recovery within policy limits. When insurance limits are insufficient to cover all losses, assessing the defendant’s personal assets may be a consideration, though practical collection realities often influence strategy. An early evaluation of available coverage and potential alternative defendants helps injured persons make informed decisions about pursuing litigation, settlement, or other avenues to address medical and financial needs arising from the injury.
Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. and the team at Ahearne Law Firm PLLC can assist by conducting an initial review of the incident, advising on deadlines and evidence preservation, and coordinating collection of medical records and other documentation relevant to a TBI claim. The firm can communicate with insurers on your behalf, arrange for necessary medical or vocational evaluations, and help determine an appropriate valuation of damages that accounts for both present and future care needs. Personalized attention helps ensure the case is developed according to the specific facts and medical realities of the injury. If negotiations with insurers do not yield a fair resolution, the firm can prepare the case for litigation, including discovery and trial preparation, while keeping you informed about options and likely outcomes. Throughout the process, the goal is to secure compensation that addresses medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, lost earnings, and the non-economic impacts of the injury so that clients can focus on recovery and planning for the future.
Explore our injury practice areas
⚖️ All Personal Injury Services