A+ rating on Better Business Bureau•Google reviews: 5.0•Martindale Hubbell Client Rating: 5.0•Lawyers.com Client Rating: 5.0•Avvo Client Rating: 5.0•Facebook Rating 5.0•Best Dog Bite Lawyers – Queens, NY (2025) (Expertise.com)•Best Bicycle Accident Lawyers – Queens, NY (2025) (Expertise.com)•Best Car Accident Lawyers – Middletown, NY (2025) (Expertise.com)•A+ rating on Better Business Bureau•Google reviews: 5.0•Martindale Hubbell Client Rating: 5.0•Lawyers.com Client Rating: 5.0•Avvo Client Rating: 5.0•Facebook Rating 5.0•Best Dog Bite Lawyers – Queens, NY (2025) (Expertise.com)•Best Bicycle Accident Lawyers – Queens, NY (2025) (Expertise.com)•Best Car Accident Lawyers – Middletown, NY (2025) (Expertise.com)

Train or Subway Accidents Lawyer in New York

Guidance After Transit Injuries

New York Train and Subway Injury Guide

New York’s trains and subways move millions each day, yet a moment of carelessness or a dangerous condition can lead to sudden, life-changing injuries. After a platform fall, door malfunction, sudden stop, or collision, the steps you take can shape your recovery. Prompt medical attention, thorough documentation, and careful communication with carriers and insurers matter. Transit systems and their contractors often control key evidence, from surveillance footage to maintenance logs, and timelines can be short. This guide explains how claims involving the MTA, Metro-North, LIRR, and city subways are evaluated, what compensation may be available, and how to protect your rights as your health and daily life are affected.

The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC represents injured riders, commuters, and workers throughout New York and the Hudson Valley in matters arising from train and subway incidents. Led by attorney Allan J. Ahearne, Jr., the firm focuses on practical case building, clear communication, and steady advocacy from first call through resolution. Whether your injury involves a crowded platform hazard or an onboard event, we tailor a plan to gather evidence, coordinate medical documentation, and address deadlines that can arrive quickly. If you or a loved one has been hurt, contact our office at (845) 986-2777 to discuss your situation and learn the options that fit your goals and timeline.

Why Legal Guidance Matters After Transit Injuries

Train and subway injury claims often involve public authorities, private contractors, and complex operating rules, which means identifying the responsible parties and preserving evidence can be challenging. Carriers typically control critical records, including surveillance video and maintenance data, and those materials may be overwritten without prompt action. Short deadlines, such as early notice requirements for certain public entities, can also affect the ability to pursue compensation for medical care, lost wages, and pain and suffering. With focused guidance, you can organize medical proof, document the impact on your daily life, and navigate insurer communications more confidently. The right plan supports timely filings, careful valuation, and a strategy that aligns with your recovery.

About The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC and Allan J. Ahearne, Jr.

At The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC, we approach train and subway cases with thorough preparation, consistent communication, and a focus on results that reflect each client’s needs. Attorney Allan J. Ahearne, Jr. leads the firm’s Personal Injury matters, representing individuals across New York and the Hudson Valley. Our team coordinates accident reconstruction, medical documentation, and claims handling with the diligence these cases demand. We understand how a transit injury can disrupt work, family, and health, and we work to move your claim forward while you focus on treatment. From the first call at (845) 986-2777 through resolution, we aim to provide steady advocacy and clear, actionable guidance at every stage.

Understanding Train and Subway Injury Claims in New York

Transit carriers are considered common carriers, which means they owe passengers a high duty of care in operating trains, maintaining equipment, and keeping platforms reasonably safe. Incidents can arise from driver or operator error, signal problems, defective doors, slippery platforms, overcrowding, or hazards created by third-party contractors. Because multiple entities may be involved, liability can include a public authority, a private maintenance company, or others who control conditions along the route. Evidence usually includes incident reports, video recordings, witness statements, and medical records linking injuries to the event. Early steps to identify and preserve these materials often shape the outcome, including whether the carrier’s own records support what happened and when.

Claims involving New York City Transit, the MTA, and related entities are subject to strict procedures and short timelines, including early notices that must be served in the correct form and on the proper parties. Some cases also require rapid requests for surveillance footage or inspection records before they are routinely overwritten. Coordinating medical care and documenting symptoms over time strengthens the connection between the incident and your injuries. While many claims resolve through negotiation, others benefit from litigation to secure testimony or compel production of key documents. Acting promptly helps align your medical recovery, evidence preservation, and filing strategy, allowing time to prepare a thorough claim without sacrificing important deadlines.

Need More Information?

Key Terms for New York Transit Claims

Common Carrier

A common carrier is a company or authority that transports the public for a fee, such as a subway or commuter rail system. In New York, common carriers owe passengers a heightened duty of care in the operation, maintenance, and supervision of trains and stations. This includes taking reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable harms, like keeping platforms safe, maintaining equipment, and operating trains with caution. When a passenger is injured, the carrier’s duties are measured against what a reasonably careful common carrier would do under similar conditions. Proving a breach of those duties often requires prompt access to records, video, and safety policies maintained by the carrier and its contractors.

Notice of Claim

A Notice of Claim is a formal document that must be served on certain public entities before filing a lawsuit. For many New York transit-related claims, this notice has a short deadline and specific content requirements. It alerts the entity to the basic facts of the incident and the nature of the injuries, allowing an opportunity to investigate. Missing the deadline or serving the wrong entity can jeopardize the claim. Because multiple authorities and subsidiaries may be involved, confirming the correct recipient and method of service is essential. Filing a Notice of Claim on time preserves your ability to later pursue compensation through court if settlement efforts fall short.

Negligence

Negligence is the failure to use reasonable care under the circumstances. In train and subway cases, negligence may involve operating a train unsafely, ignoring platform hazards, or failing to maintain equipment like doors, brakes, and signals. To prove negligence, you generally show a duty of care, a breach of that duty, and that the breach caused your injuries and losses. Evidence often includes incident reports, video recordings, maintenance logs, and medical records linking the condition to the harm. When multiple parties share responsibilities, each can be assessed for their role in creating or failing to correct the dangerous condition that led to the passenger’s injury.

Statute of Limitations

The statute of limitations sets the legal deadline to file a lawsuit. In New York, the deadline depends on the nature of the claim and whether the defendant is a public authority. Some transit matters require a Notice of Claim well before any lawsuit can be started, and certain entities have shorter filing periods than private defendants. Missing a deadline can bar recovery regardless of the claim’s merits. Because timelines vary by entity and claim type, it is important to identify the correct deadlines early. Aligning your medical documentation, evidence gathering, and legal filings with these time limits helps preserve your right to seek compensation.

PRO TIPS

Report the Incident Promptly

If you’re hurt, report the incident to station personnel, train staff, or the appropriate authority as soon as it is safe to do so. Ask for an incident or occurrence number and confirm where the report will be stored, then keep copies of any paperwork or reference details. Prompt reporting helps preserve surveillance footage, maintenance records, and witness information that could be overwritten or lost as routine operations continue, ensuring your version of events is anchored by official documentation when your claim is reviewed.

Preserve Evidence Early

Take photos or videos of the scene, your injuries, and any visible hazards such as wet platforms, broken tiles, or malfunctioning doors. Save your fare card, trip receipts, medical discharge notes, and the names and contacts of witnesses or employees who assisted. Early preservation allows your claim to be supported by tangible proof, making it easier to reconstruct what happened and to counter later disputes about conditions, timing, or the severity of your injuries.

Seek Medical Evaluation

Get a prompt medical evaluation even if you believe you can manage symptoms at home, as some injuries evolve over hours or days. Tell providers exactly how the incident occurred so your records reflect a clear link between the event and your complaints. Consistent follow-up care not only supports healing, but also creates a clear record of pain, limitations, and treatment, which is important when insurers or authorities assess the legitimacy and value of your claim.

Comparing Legal Paths for Transit Injuries

When Full Representation Makes Sense:

Multiple Parties and Complex Fault

Transit cases often involve overlapping responsibilities among public authorities, private maintenance contractors, and security vendors, creating complex questions of fault. Full representation helps coordinate evidence requests, depositions, and expert evaluations to pinpoint accountability and prove how each party’s conduct contributed to the injury. This approach is valuable when records are dispersed, witnesses are numerous, and the defense raises technical arguments about operations, safety policies, or compliance standards.

Severe Injuries and Long-Term Losses

Serious injuries often require careful documentation of future care, lost earning capacity, and how daily life is affected, which can be contested. A comprehensive strategy supports medical evaluations, economic analysis, and thorough negotiation aimed at covering both immediate and future needs. When settlement offers undervalue long-term consequences, full representation positions your claim for litigation to pursue a result that reflects the true scope of your losses.

When Limited Assistance May Work:

Minor Injuries With Clear Liability

If injuries are minor, recover quickly, and the carrier promptly accepts clear responsibility, a limited approach can be appropriate. Assistance may focus on organizing medical records, confirming out-of-pocket costs, and drafting a targeted demand that reflects a short treatment window. This streamlined path can reduce delay and expense while still ensuring the claim is supported by accurate, complete documentation.

Property Damage or Minimal Care

Some events involve mostly property damage or minimal medical needs, such as brief evaluation and release with no follow-up. In these situations, limited guidance can help you communicate efficiently with insurers and confirm a fair resolution without extensive litigation steps. The focus remains on preserving essential records, avoiding misstatements, and resolving the matter in a way that reflects the actual impact of the incident.

Frequent Scenarios in Train and Subway Cases

Door Malfunctions and Platform Falls

Passengers may be caught in closing doors or fall due to gaps, uneven surfaces, or slippery substances on platforms. Documenting the condition, securing witness information, and requesting relevant maintenance records can help show how the hazard was created or allowed to persist and why reasonable measures would have prevented the injury.

Sudden Stops and Onboard Collisions

Unexpected braking or collisions can throw standing riders or seated passengers into poles, seats, or other riders, causing neck, back, and head injuries. Timely reports, video retrieval, and medical evaluations create a clear picture of force, mechanism, and resulting harm, which can be essential when liability or severity is disputed.

Track Worker or Contractor Injuries

Workers exposed to moving trains, electrical systems, or hazardous equipment may face layered claims involving employment benefits and third-party liability. Coordinating incident documentation, safety protocols, and contractor responsibilities helps determine whether additional recovery is available beyond workers’ compensation benefits.

New York Train and Subway Accident Attorney

Why Choose The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC

Transit cases demand careful coordination of evidence, medical proof, and deadlines. At The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC, we build claims with a steady focus on timely notice, thorough documentation, and practical negotiation aimed at meaningful results. We pursue incident reports, surveillance footage, and maintenance data early, and we work with your providers to capture the full impact of injuries on work, family, and daily routines. Whether the matter involves the MTA, NYC Transit, Metro-North, or LIRR, we tailor each step to the entity involved and the realities of your recovery. From first call through resolution, our approach emphasizes preparation and communication you can rely on.

Your case deserves attention, planning, and a strategy that reflects your goals. We take the time to understand how the incident has affected your health and finances, and we align the path forward with your priorities, whether that involves negotiation or litigation. Our office serves clients throughout New York and the Hudson Valley, and we are available to discuss the process, answer questions, and begin preserving key evidence. To talk about your situation and timelines that may apply, contact The Ahearne Law Firm PLLC at (845) 986-2777. We are ready to help you move from uncertainty toward a clear plan focused on recovery and accountability.

Call for a Free Case Review

People Also Search For

New York train accident lawyer

subway injury attorney NYC

MTA accident claim New York

NYC Transit Authority injury

Metro-North accident attorney

LIRR injury lawyer New York

subway platform fall claim

train door malfunction injury

FAQS

What should I do after a train or subway accident in New York?

Start by seeking medical care, even if symptoms seem manageable, because injuries can develop over time. Report the incident to station staff, train personnel, or the proper authority and ask how to obtain a copy of the occurrence report. Take photos of the scene, your injuries, and any hazards you noticed, and save your fare card or trip receipts. Collect names and contact information for witnesses if possible. Avoid detailed statements to insurers before you understand your rights, and note any cameras, signage, or conditions that might support what happened. Within days, request that relevant surveillance footage and maintenance records be preserved, as many systems overwrite video quickly. Keep a diary of symptoms, work limitations, and out-of-pocket costs to help document the claim’s impact. Follow up with your healthcare providers and attend recommended appointments. When you are ready, contact a lawyer familiar with New York transit matters to discuss deadlines, including any required Notice of Claim, and to align your evidence with the legal standards that apply.

Who can be held liable for a subway or train injury in New York?

Liability can involve several parties, including a public authority like NYC Transit, the MTA, or a commuter rail, as well as private contractors responsible for maintenance, cleaning, station construction, or security. In some cases, another rider’s careless conduct or a third party’s hazardous condition may play a role. Determining fault often requires incident reports, witness statements, video footage, and maintenance logs. Each entity’s policies and responsibilities help show who controlled the dangerous condition and whether reasonable steps would have prevented the injury. Because multiple parties may share responsibility, evidence must be gathered promptly and targeted to the facts. A careful investigation can reveal whether door sensors malfunctioned, cleaning protocols were ignored, or an operator reacted unreasonably to conditions. Establishing liability can also depend on notice, meaning whether the entity knew or should have known about a hazard in time to correct it. Coordinating these pieces early supports a clear path to accountability and compensation.

How long do I have to file a claim after a train or subway incident?

Deadlines vary, and some transit cases require a Notice of Claim on a short timetable before any lawsuit may be filed. Claims against certain public authorities have filing periods that can be much shorter than standard personal injury deadlines, so early action is important. Because specific requirements differ between entities, confirming the correct timeline and proper recipient is essential to protect your rights. Missing a notice or limitations deadline can bar recovery regardless of the claim’s merits. In addition to formal deadlines, practical timing matters for evidence like surveillance video and maintenance records that may be routinely overwritten. Prompt requests to preserve materials, timely medical evaluations, and consistent treatment create a record that supports causation and damages. Once your timeline is confirmed, you can align negotiation or litigation steps with the deadlines to maintain leverage and keep your claim moving forward without sacrificing important rights.

What compensation may be available for a transit-related injury?

Available compensation may include medical expenses, future treatment, lost wages, diminished earning capacity, and damages for pain and suffering. In some cases, out-of-pocket costs for transportation, medications, and household help are recoverable if connected to the injury. The extent of recovery depends on the severity of harm, how long symptoms persist, and whether limitations affect work and daily activities. Thorough medical records and consistent care help quantify both present and future needs. Proving damages involves more than bills and receipts. Documentation of your day-to-day challenges, provider notes on functional limitations, and support from treating professionals can help capture the true impact of the incident. When injuries are significant, the claim may also consider future medical procedures, rehabilitation, and vocational consequences. Detailed evidence puts you in the best position to evaluate settlement offers and decide whether litigation is warranted to pursue a fair outcome.

Do I need to file a Notice of Claim against the MTA or Transit Authority?

Many claims against public transit entities require a timely Notice of Claim that sets out the basics of what happened and the injuries involved. The notice must be served on the correct entity within a short window, and mistakes in timing or service can jeopardize the case. Because multiple authorities and subsidiaries operate in New York, identifying the proper recipient is essential. The Notice of Claim preserves the right to bring a lawsuit later if settlement discussions do not resolve the matter. Filing the notice is only one step. You may also be scheduled for a hearing or examination under oath, and additional documentation will likely be requested. Keeping organized records and communicating carefully helps maintain credibility. With deadlines running quickly, coordinating the notice, evidence preservation, and medical proof at the same time ensures you meet requirements while preparing a compelling claim.

How is evidence gathered in train and subway cases?

Evidence commonly includes incident reports, surveillance video, photographs, witness statements, and maintenance or inspection logs. When door malfunctions, platform hazards, or signal issues are suspected, requests can be made to preserve equipment data and records before they are overwritten. Medical records are equally important, as they connect the incident to diagnosed injuries, treatment plans, and functional limitations. A prompt and organized approach increases the odds that key materials will be available when needed. Collecting evidence also involves documenting the human side of the claim, such as pain levels, disrupted work, and changes to daily routines. Journals, employer notes, and statements from family or caregivers can illustrate how the injury affects your life. In disputes about how an incident occurred, technical experts may be consulted to analyze video, forces involved, or equipment function. Together, these pieces create a clear picture of what happened and why accountability is warranted.

How do insurance claims interact with claims against public authorities?

Some losses may be addressed through insurance coverage, while others are pursued against public authorities or contractors. Health insurance can help with treatment, and liens may apply that must be resolved from any recovery. Where available, certain benefits may cover part of your costs while the liability claim is investigated or negotiated. Coordinating these sources helps prevent gaps in care and avoids surprises at settlement. Claims against public authorities follow specific procedures that run alongside insurance handling. It’s important to keep all carriers informed, maintain accurate records, and track deadlines so coverage is not interrupted and rights are preserved. When a settlement is reached, lien resolution and documentation ensure benefits are handled properly. With a coordinated plan, you can manage treatment, coverage, and the liability claim in a way that supports both your health and your legal position.

What if I was partially at fault for the incident?

New York applies comparative fault, which means your compensation can be reduced in proportion to your share of responsibility, but you are not barred from recovery solely because you were partly at fault. The key is to gather evidence that fairly reflects the carrier’s or contractor’s role in creating or failing to fix a dangerous condition. Even if you were standing near a door or moving quickly on a platform, the law still examines whether the entity acted reasonably under the circumstances. Because carriers control many of the records, preserving surveillance footage, incident reports, and maintenance data is essential to a fair assessment. Medical documentation connecting injuries to the incident helps counter arguments that symptoms were unrelated. With clear evidence and careful presentation, the claim can reflect the full story, including the responsibilities of the carrier and other parties, rather than focusing solely on your actions at a single moment.

How much does it cost to hire a train or subway accident lawyer?

Many personal injury cases are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning legal fees are collected only if there is a recovery, and the fee is a percentage of the outcome. Case costs, such as records, experts, or filing fees, are typically discussed at the outset so there are no surprises about how expenses are handled. During a free consultation, fee structures and expectations can be explained in plain terms so you can decide what works best for you. Every case is different, and the complexity, evidence needs, and potential litigation steps can affect the overall cost. Transparency about fees and expenses allows you to weigh the benefits of representation against the resources required. If you have questions about costs, ask for a written explanation and updates as the case progresses. Clear communication helps you stay in control of decisions and ensures your financial interests are respected.

What should I bring to my first consultation about a transit injury?

Bring any incident or occurrence numbers, medical records, discharge paperwork, imaging results, and contact information for witnesses or employees who assisted. Photos or videos of the scene, your injuries, and the hazard are helpful, along with your fare card, receipts, and notes about public announcements or signage. A timeline of symptoms and missed work days provides context, and a list of questions ensures you cover what matters most to you during the meeting. If available, bring correspondence from insurers or the transit authority, including requests for statements or forms. A brief summary of your medical history and prior injuries helps anticipate defense arguments and keeps the focus on the incident’s impact. With these materials, your lawyer can assess deadlines, evidence needs, and next steps. Together, you can map out a plan to preserve video, request records, and align your treatment documentation with the legal standards that apply.